The “Good Side” of the Fence: Is There a Correct Way to Install It?

When installing a new fence, the structural choices are straightforward, but the aesthetic and social decisions can be surprisingly complicated. A common point of contention between homeowners and their neighbors is which direction the fence should face. Should the “pretty” side—the smooth, finished surface without visible support beams—face the neighbor, or should the person paying for the fence get to enjoy the view?

The short answer is that it depends on where you live, what your local ordinances say, and how much value you place on neighborly relations. While there is no universal law that dictates the orientation of every fence, there are strong conventions, practical considerations, and in many municipalities, specific legal requirements that must be followed.

Understanding the “Good” and “Bad” Sides

To understand the debate, it helps to clarify what is meant by the “good” side. In most traditional wooden privacy fences, one side displays the flat, finished pickets or boards, while the other side exposes the horizontal support rails (stringers) and the fence posts.

The side with the flat pickets is universally considered the “good” or “finished” side. The side with the visible rails and posts is often referred to as the “bad” or “unfinished” side, as it is less aesthetically pleasing and can look utilitarian.

The Case for Facing the Neighbor

The long-standing tradition in many communities is that the finished side should face outward, toward the neighbor or the street. This is often viewed as a gesture of goodwill. The reasoning is that you are erecting a barrier that affects your neighbor’s view, so you should give them the more attractive side to look at.

Beyond etiquette, there are practical and safety reasons for this convention. Putting the rails on the inside of your yard means the smooth side faces out, which makes it significantly harder for people to climb over the fence. A smooth surface offers no footholds, whereas the horizontal rails on the inside could act as a ladder. Additionally, placing the rails on the inside allows you to see any damage to the fence structure more easily, and it makes installing gate latches simpler.

In many jurisdictions, this convention is not just a suggestion but a legal requirement. Numerous municipal codes, such as those in Biloxi, Mississippi, and Blasdell, New York, explicitly state that the finished side of the fence must face outward toward the adjoining lot or street. The rationale is often to preserve the aesthetic integrity of the neighborhood and ensure that the backs of fences are not visible to the public or neighbors enjoying their yards.

The Case for Facing Yourself

On the other hand, many homeowners argue that if they are paying for the fence, they should get the benefit of the “good” side. This perspective is particularly common when the fence is being installed entirely on the homeowner’s property and at their sole expense.

In these situations, there is often no legal obligation to face the fence outward, provided local zoning codes do not specify otherwise. Some homeowners choose to face the finished side inward so they can enjoy the clean look from their own patio or garden. In this scenario, the neighbor sees the rails. While this might go against the tradition of neighborly courtesy, it is perfectly legal in many areas where no specific ordinance exists.

Some contractors have even noted that in the absence of a code requirement, the person paying for the project gets to make the final call on orientation.

Checking Your Local Codes and Property Deeds

Given the variation in rules, the most critical step before installation is to check your local municipal codes. Fence regulations are typically handled by city or county zoning departments, and they vary widely.

Some cities have strict “good side out” ordinances for fences facing streets or neighbors. Others have no orientation requirements at all. It is also essential to check your property deed or plat map to determine who actually owns the boundary line. If the fence is being installed on a boundary you own, you have more say in the matter, provided you adhere to local codes. If it is a shared boundary, you may need to negotiate with your neighbor before making any changes.

Alternative Solutions: Double-Sided Fences

If the debate over which side looks better is causing friction, there are fence designs that eliminate the problem entirely. A “shadowbox” or “good neighbor” fence is a style where the pickets are alternated on both sides of the rails. This creates a finished, attractive appearance on both sides of the fence, offering privacy without sacrificing aesthetics for either party.

Another option is a double-sided fence, where pickets are attached to both sides of the framework. While this is more expensive and uses more materials, it provides a completely finished look to both properties and is often considered the ultimate compromise.

Conclusion

So, is there a correct way to install a fence? The answer is yes, but the definition of “correct” depends on your location. If your city code requires the finished side to face out, then that is the correct way, and violating it could result in fines or a requirement to rebuild. If your area has no such code, then the “correct” way is a matter of personal preference, negotiation, and neighborly consideration.

For those seeking to maintain a positive relationship with their neighbors, following the traditional etiquette of facing the finished side outward is often the safest and most respectful choice. However, for homeowners who have invested significantly in their property and are not bound by local ordinances, choosing to face the finished side inward is a valid personal decision.

Ultimately, the best approach is to communicate with your neighbor, understand your local regulations, and choose a solution that balances your aesthetic preferences with the realities of your property line and community standards.

Leave a Comment